Someone Please educate me.
Someone Please educate me.
Generally it's due to gang affiliation, or contextual gang affiliation from decades ago. Same reason they outlaw the carry of nunchuku, throwing stars, daggers, and other various weapons when in most the same cities you can open-carry a pistol. Laws are blanket-fixes to problems of the time (like the ninja fad) and slow to change back to normalcy. More people get killed with blunt objects and improvised stabbing tools than expensive produced ones.
A Para2 is quicker and just as deadly as a balisong. They just didn't have it as the tool of choice for every crime-boss in a 80's action movie. ;)
Only logical reasons I can come up with, which may not hold merit. Would be *if* balisongs and switchblades were as popular amongst gangsters as we are led to believe (by movies) that this would have given cops a good reason to stop and search such people. This could then lead to other weapons drugs money etc. Where if they were legal the cops would be forced to let them go with no reason to search.
OR, because you tend to 'play' with a balisong you could argue that they tough guy on the train/bus/etc was playing with his knife as oppose to brandishing to others around him/her.
Its the only way I can make a logical argument.
That said, I would welcome these laws being reversed as the first Spyderco I wanted was the Spyderfly. Prohibited where I live so that's never going to happen.
It's pointless to look for a logical reason, as there is no logical reason why they (meaning the government) restrict any kind of knives. They don't use logic, they use scare tactics and emotional appeal to make it seem like "knives are bad", and for the majority of the public, it works.
In a nutshell, lawmakers are raciest.
Also they do not use educated judgement but what they think is needed.
They don't seem to search out experts, educate the public then base decision on that rather they use fear, gut reaction, and their position to determine their course of action.
Examples, are fixed blades safer/more dangerous that folders? One handed openers vs two? Locking vs non-locking? etc etc.
I recall an article in The Lancet about 10 years ago (UK Registered Doctor's periodical) exorting the UK Goverment to consider a ban on chefs knives
Reasoning: The majority of fatal and serious wounds that are treated in A&E (ER to you Colonial types ;) ) are from 6-7" long kitchen knives with narrow thickness but broad blades.
The Lancet considered them to be 'especially dangerous' because they are flexible (Meaning that they tend to deflect or bend around bones to penetrate deeper and are more likely to result in a fatal penetration of an organ) readily available and cheap- You can buy poor quality Chinese kitchen knives for £1 in Poundland.
Nothing came of it.
When the tabloids and movies want send a shiver down the spines of the general public they use the 'clickety-clack' of a balisong or switchblade.....Governments therefore react to the paranoia.
In reality, those poor souls getting stitched up in A&E on a Saturday night haven't been on the recieving end of a £100+ restricted knife, but the cheap 'n' nasty throwaway kitchen knife :(
It's just a leftover Hollywood "knife fight" stigma that has stuck to that particular type of knife just as it has to automatics. It's stupid since the reality is almost anyone can deploy a standard thumb hole Spydero knife faster than a well trained bali user. Personally I don't think I would carry one anyway even if they were legal, because I find using them to be too fidgety but there are some that I wouldn't mind owning, and I would especially like to own a nice Italian stiletto automatic if they were legal here. I still don't know if I'd carry one, but I'd still like the option to own it.
I do own a Parker Cutlery brass handled "surgical stainless" bali that I've had since I was probably 10 years old, and when I was younger I did carry that knife everywhere and use it for everything, I just didn't flip it about and attract attention with it.
Demoncase and Evil D
The "kitchen knife" is easily available, cheap and dangerous. If your spending $50+ on a weapon that's not a gun your in the wrong game. I'd buy the $2-10 dollar store big knife, sharp enough for one real use and scarier than any Spyderco I can draw. If I see a 6 inch kitchen knife this dude means business.
Btw imho the scariest knife scenes come from horror movies when the killer draws the big kitchen knife from the wood block, in the victims home....
I'd carry a bali if legal, until A) I don't see them as practical and outgrow the novelty or B) find they are not as functional as the current available fixed/folders. I'd buy some though for sure, even just as 'toys'
Sorry that wasn't very clear. I did mean bad guys. There are a variety of knives available in dollar stores that are legal to own (a police stop brings up other issues).
*If* I was a criminal, I wouldn't be looking for $100 balisongs or even standard Spydercos, I'm looking for cheap 'one time use' knives that I can throw away and not keep evidence sitting in my house.
Also the average criminal does not care about laws, so blade length, illegal firearms, robbery and murder are not things they consider, these are things for you and I to follow.
The average crime would not be with a chef's knife but if you plan to do something horrible you might consider it for the scare factor, just like people love the big Ka-bars.
If we're talking regular knife use/edc there is nothing wrong with a bali or switch because your use and intent of the knife is to open packages cut food ect, same as every other knife.
The truly illegal part of any tool is the user. Be it a gun of any sort, knife, hammer or pencil. Making the item illegal does not change the mindset of a dangerous person.
Well, my guess is that, like guns, criminals aren't paying full price for these kinds of knives when they get them.
Hollywood. That is all